
Take a look at the outfits Francie is wearing in Views G and H above. What fabric do you suspect they want you to use, when sewing these garments?
Denim, right? I mean, yeah, the red and white striped long-sleeved tee shirt should be made from stretchy fabric like jersey probably, but the pants and jacket, and even that “ball cap” in views G and H definitely give you the impression they’re made of lightweight denim or cotton that looks sort of like denim, right?
Before I go on, I need to make my required disclaimer statement: As an Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. To learn more about how affiliate marketing works on my website, please go to the Privacy Policy page. Thank you!

For anyone who’s new to sewing, the back of a pattern envelope offers you lots of great ideas, like what notions you’ll need, how much fabric to buy, and even suggested fabrics. It’s usually worth looking at this information before you start to sew a garment.
But look at the “Suggested Fabrics” section above, for View G and H on this McCall’s 8531 pattern for Francie dolls. (That’s the line at Francie’s eye level, on the back of the pattern envelope.)
Yep, you read that right: “G. Pants and Cap — Felt ONLY. H. Jacket — Felt or Vinyl ONLY.”
I read that and went…

Sometimes when I open a pattern and read the directions, I say to myself, “Who on earth designed this? What on earth were they thinking?”
And in the case of these FELT PANTS, my first instinct was, “Uh… That’s not gonna work.”
For those of us who grew up in the 1970’s, all dolls, including Francie, had flesh-like skin on their legs. Modern Barbies don’t usually have this fleshy-feeling skin. They’re generally made of shiny plastic. But for the dolls of the 1970’s, it’s tricky to get any kind of pants on those sticky legs. Felt, I was pretty sure, would be very awkward to put on your Francie doll.
But over the years, I’ve found that sometimes I can learn a thing or two by attempting to make a pattern following the directions given, so that’s what I decided to do with this View G pair of bell-bottom pants for Francie, from McCall’s 8531.

Before I criticize this pattern designer, I need to state a couple of caveats: first, I traced my patterns onto graph paper, as you can see in Figure 1 above, which means there’s going to be some margin of error; second, today’s felt is not like the felt from the 1960’s and 1970’s.
Back in my grandmother’s day, felt was made of wool, and I believe it was a lot sturdier than the felt we use today. Today’s felt is often made of polyester (a plastic product), and it can easily pull apart when you sew it.
Because of this “pull-apart” issue, I chose a particularly thick piece of felt for my pants. But right away, I could see that this was problematic. The pants fly, when closed, was about four millimeters thick.
I wondered if these pants would fit Francie at all. I suspected they would be waaaay too tight.

Let’s have a look at how these turned out. Do they fit? Yes. Mostly.
Clearly the designer of this McCall’s 8531 sewing pattern left us plenty of room for give, and their pattern allowed the extra room that would have been needed for the thicker wool felt that was common back when this pattern was first published. I applaud him/her for that.
But do these pants fit the way they should? Ummm… nope. Not if you’re going by the artwork on the front of the envelope, anyway.
What you can’t see in these photos was my struggle with trying to get these fuzzy felt trousers up the skin-like legs of the doll. As I had first suspected, getting the pants on and off the doll was a hassle. I don’t think I’ll make this pattern again, but if I do decide to give it another try, I’m going to make significant alterations and use lightweight denim or a denim-blue cotton fabric instead.
Questions: What do you know about the varieties of felt that were offered back in the 1960’s and 1970’s? And how are felts today different? Do you like to sew with modern felt? Or have you had issues with using felt for dolls’ clothes?
Please leave your thoughts on sewing with felt in the comments area below. I do read and respond to them!
Here are 3 ways you can help support my website and YouTube channel:
- Buy some of my own fabric designs, which are found in my Spoonflower store where I have a curated collection of fabrics for sewing doll clothes!
- Buy something you need or want from my Etsy store
- For teachers or librarians, purchase something from my Teachers Pay Teachers store
To read more about my free sewing patterns and tutorials, please visit the “Helpful Tips” page.
Disclaimer/Credit/Affiliate Marketing Link:
*Please note: when you click on links to various merchants on the ChellyWood.com site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include Amazon, Etsy, and the eBay Partner Network. As an Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. To learn more about how my website uses affiliate marketing, please visit the website’s Privacy Policy page.
Chelly Wood and the ChellyWood.com website are not affiliated with the pattern company or companies mentioned in this blog post, but Chelly finds inspiration in the doll clothes designed by these pattern companies. To purchase patterns from Simplicity, McCall’s, Butterick, Vogue, or other pattern companies shown and discussed in this blog post, please click on the links provided here. These links below the “Disclaimer” section do not help raise money for this free pattern website; they are only offered to give credit to the company that made these patterns.
